top of page
Search

The Health Insurance Headache: Common Issues Small Business Owners Face (And How to Fix Them)

You didn’t start your business to become an insurance expert—but somehow here you are, knee-deep in premiums, paperwork, and policies, trying to take care of your people without breaking the bank.

Sound familiar? You’re not alone.

As a broker working with small business owners across PA, NY, MD, MI, and FL, I’ve seen firsthand the real-life frustrations—and the moments of clarity—that come with offering health insurance. This blog isn’t a sales pitch. It’s a breakdown of the most common issues small businesses face with health insurance and real-world solutions that work.




💸 Sticker Shock: “Wait… how much?”

One of the first things business owners say when we sit down to talk benefits is: “I had no idea it would cost this much.”

Health insurance is a major expense—and for smaller companies without big corporate buying power, it can feel downright unaffordable. Many owners assume they're stuck with whatever rates the big-name carriers throw their way. But there are options.

Affordable Health Plan Solutions:

  • Level-funded plans blend the benefits of traditional group coverage with cost control and potential savings.

  • Industry-specific carriers are popping up with plans built for niche sectors (like construction, cannabis, and hospitality).

  • Broker negotiations can uncover discounts or bundling opportunities you might not see on your own.

🧠 Pro Tip: We helped a 7-person construction company in PA save nearly $15,000 a year just by switching to a better-fit carrier.






👥 One-Size-Fits-All Plans Don’t Fit Anyone

Your 22-year-old marketing assistant wants cheap preventive care and telehealth. Your 48-year-old warehouse supervisor needs solid family coverage. Yet most small businesses start out offering just one plan.

Why Employee Choice Matters: When employees feel like a plan doesn’t fit their life, satisfaction drops. That directly impacts retention and morale.

Flexible Coverage Options:

  • Offer two plan options: a leaner plan with lower premiums and a richer plan with more coverage.

  • Add voluntary benefits like dental, vision, life, or accident insurance.

  • Pair HDHPs with HSAs to give more flexibility and tax-advantaged savings.

✅ Quick Win: Even one additional plan can drastically increase satisfaction.

🧠 Real-Life Example: A boutique retail shop in NY with 10 employees was seeing high turnover due to poor benefits. We introduced two medical plan options and bundled dental and vision. Within 3 months, two former employees returned—and the owner saw a measurable boost in morale.





🧾 Compliance Chaos

ACA, COBRA, HIPAA, ERISA... the acronyms alone can feel overwhelming. Small business owners are often surprised by how much compliance responsibility they hold, especially once they hit certain employee thresholds.

Compliance Risks to Avoid: Missing a required notice or mishandling COBRA can lead to steep fines.

Staying Compliant Made Simple:

  • Work with a broker or TPA to stay updated and organized.

  • Conduct annual compliance audits.

  • Use HR software with built-in compliance features.

📎 Remember: Even unintentional mistakes can lead to penalties. Proactive planning protects you.





📣 Communication Breakdown

Even the best insurance plan is useless if employees don’t understand how to use it. Most workers don't know the difference between a copay and coinsurance—and they certainly aren't clear on what their plan covers.

Boost Employee Understanding:

  • Host clear onboarding sessions during hiring and renewals.

  • Provide simple one-pagers explaining key benefits.

  • Schedule quarterly Q&A sessions with your broker.

💡 Insight: Educated employees use benefits more effectively—and appreciate them more.








🧢 Trying to Handle Everything Solo

Small business owners wear enough hats. Adding "benefits manager" to the list can lead to burnout, missed details, and constant stress.

Relief Is Available:

  • Work with a dedicated broker who understands your business.

  • Set up a year-round support strategy.

  • Use tech tools to automate enrollments and updates.

🙌 Takeaway: You don’t have to do it all. A trusted partner lightens the load.



✅ Real-life client Example

Last year, I worked with a small marketing agency in MD. They had 12 employees and were on a plan that had gone up 18%—again. No one had ever explained their options.

We helped them:

  • Switch to a level-funded plan

  • Add dental and vision at a minimal increase

  • Offer a 401(k) through one of our partners

  • Host a Q&A with the whole team

Not only did they cut costs by 12%, but employee satisfaction (and retention) improved across the board.


❤️ Bonus Tip: Don’t Forget the "Why"

Offering health insurance isn’t just about compliance or competition. It’s about taking care of your people so they can take care of your business. When your team feels secure and supported, performance goes up, and turnover goes down.

At Houtz Insurance, we believe every business deserves a benefits strategy that fits its budget, team, and goals.



Ready for Less Stress and Better Coverage?

At Houtz Insurance, we don’t just quote and run. We take the time to understand your business, your people, and your goals so we can build a strategy that works now and scales with you as you grow.

Let’s take the health insurance headaches off your plate.

👉 Book a free strategy session: https://calendly.com/cheryl-houtzinsurancellc/30min

📞 Or just give me a call or text: 610-207-6819

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page